More On Lily Evans

I have read in several websites that there will be more info on Lily Evans in the last book. "Harry has his father and mother's good looks. But he has his mother's eyes and that's very important in a future book. Rowling has also said there will be more details about Lily in the seventh and final Harry Potter book, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows." Do you also think that Lily had dated Snape at one time? Maybe that could be another in which he hates Harry so much because he could have been his son with her. Rowling did say that Snape did not have a dughter but she never said that she did bot have a son.

Didn't Lily also work in the Department of Mysteries at some point? Or am I mixing that up with some theory I read somewhere?

IDK. I never heard that before. I thinking you read it in a theory.
Well, I don't think that Snape has any kids what so ever. I also don't think that Lily went out with Snape.

Lily just had a lot of compassion, that's all.

Probably. Ok, thanks.

I think Snape had a major thing for Lily. She was nice to him but that was where it ended. Snape hated James anyway and became even more bitter when he ended up with the girl he liked. I think he hates Harry because he is a reminder that James got his girl.

I agree with you. Lily stuck up for Snape when James picked on him, and even though he was nasty to her, he appreciated her standing up to his archenemy. I think Snape's (Professor Snape!) guilt and reason for protecting Harry stems from his love for Lily.

Exactly!!! I think it's really hard for Snape because he loved Lily and so therefore feels the need to protect Harry. But he hated James and so also hates Harry. Very mixed up feelings.

I agree that Snape may have had some feelings for Lily...but he didn't get it in return...only half the love there.

His mom was the only woman who ever loved him, and he loved his mom, but despised his father's "muggle-ness". Only half the love one normally shows towards their parents.

All of these half good, half bad situations really personify Snape's character. He knows what it is to be good, but he has done some terrible things. We've seen him flip-flop (at least it appears this way) several times throughout the series.

Either he has been abused so many times that he's gone evil to seek revenge on the world with Lord Voldy-things, or he's good (I think so) and he'll show his true colors in the last book and help Harry...eventually.

Yeah, definately could be. Or maybe he despised his Dad for the way he treated his Mum and so then turned against muggles because of this. I think that could be why he turned to Voldemort.

I agree with this too and perhaps Dumbledore is half blood or muggleborn which is why Snape realised that not all muggles are bad (maybe).

I agree with this too and perhaps Dumbledore is half blood or muggleborn which is why Snape realised that not all muggles are bad (maybe).
[/b][/quote]
You're almost on the same page as me. I'm saying that Snape has been a good guy the whole time, not that he was swayed by DD to be nice to muggleborns or whatever.

Snape has merely distanced himself from Harry so he can help him right under Voldemort's nose without either Voldemort or Harry ever knowing. By making Harry hate him like that...knowing that Harry never mastered Occlumency...Voldemort will never doubt Severus' loyalty, even though he's helping Harry to destroy the Dark Lord.