Harry As A Horcrux

1.Is Harry really a Horcrux?
2.Is it possible?
3.Does it fit Voldemort's nature to use Harry?

1.No.Harry isn't a horcrux.
2.No.It isn't possible.Voldemprt's soul was stripped from his body therefore he is unable to utilise his wand.
3.No.It doesn't fit Voldemort's nature to use Harry as a Horcrux.Voldemort is supposed to use objects that have significance to him.Objects that have a link to Hogwarts.Harry is neither an object of Voldemort's desire or an object linked to Hogwarts.

I find it extremely disconcerting that websites are dead certain that Harry is a Horcrux.Logical thought dismisses this idea.Most certainly, if you consider this thoroughly you will see the light in my logic and come to agree with me in due time.

Although I haven't spared the Harry is a Horcrux theory much thought, I hated the idea right from the start. It has been argued alot on here as to whether a Horcrux can be made accidentally. I seem to remember that the wizard has to say an incantation or something in order to create a Horcrux. If this is true, then I doubt Voldemort will have made Harry a Horcrux meaningfully as he was out to kill him anyway. There is no point in guarding part of your soul in something that you're about to destroy. So will people please give it a rest with scaring us with all these crazy theories? I'm with you all the way Malekai.

My sentiments EXACTLY!!! I thought i was alone in the world by saying Harry isn't a Horcrux.It just doesn't make sense...! And i lie to you not! This is the exact wording of a site i visited: "And as we KNOW Harry is the Horcrux, we think he'll defeat Voldemort but then sacrifice himself" This is about as crazy as things could possibly be.

SIMPLY OUTRAGEOUS!!!

But thanks for standing by me on this point.

He wouldn't make the person he's trying to kill a horcrux. It's not logical. He would only undo his own work. And that would be a waste of time, and it could possiblely expose LV.

The theory says that it was an ACCIDENT. But don't worry -- it's not life-threatening to Harry.

This is from the Fan Fiction section, my "Shacklebolt" thread, post #16, "Bob and the Accidental Horcrux"

The basic theory goes like this:

Remember Aunt Marge -- accidents can happen when one is upset, angry or frightened. Harry was not in control.

When Voldemort arrived at Godric's Hollow, Dumbledore said that he was prepared to create a horcrux. That means that whatever he needed -- materials, equipment, intention, mindset, prior meditation -- whatever it takes, he had it with him at that moment. He was good to go. His intended victim (the fresh kill that a horcrux seems to require) was Harry. The intended recepticle for the horcrux we do not know.

When Voldemort's spell backfired, he was ripped from his body and he was not in control. Stuff happens. The "fresh kill" ended up being Lily and/or James, and the recepticle for the shard of Voldemort's soul ended up being Harry.

For lack of a better one, I have given the name, “Bob” to the individual dementor who attacked Harry by the lake when he had been instructed to look for Sirius.

That's three times the dementors singled Harry out. They also tried to attack him on the train and at that Quiddich game. Both times, adult wizards drove them away.

Because Harry is an accidental horcrux, he somehow stands out to them. They can probably sense in Harry the evil shard of Voldemort's soul. Dementors are blind. They were instructed to look for a murderer. This theory says that "Bob" was just following instructions, bypassing the innocent soul and attacking the evil one.

Cornelius Fudge understands and is able to talk to the dementors. They told him that Sirius had been "talking in his sleep," and they were angrier than he had ever seem them.

If asked, can "Bob" explain his actions on that day by the lake?

A "dementor's kiss" removes the soul while leaving the person technically alive. Can "Bob" provide treatment? Can he remove the shard without harming Harry? Some of the horcruxes might be cursed or have special protections added after the fact. This shard will not.

P.S.: If this theory is correct, it won't slow Voldemort down in his attempt to kill Harry. He hates Harry more than he loves the shard. He never intended to create it in the first place.

Where did you see that? I'll go and straighten them out.

Your welcome Malekai. I'm glad I'm not the only one too! And thanks to Luna too. So Psyduck. You think he is a Horcrux? I don't believe a Horcrux can be made by accident. It's too powerful an enchantment.

But wait, I just remembered another thread that will put a spin on things. See when LV did get his soul ripped from his body it wasn't destroyed. And a good explanation for it not being destroyed would be it went into Harry. And then oh... this is how Harry could defeat LV. Oh this isn't the bittersweet ending I was hoping for. But I could be wrong. It's just another thought of mine.

Just a question: If Harry is a Horcrux, is there any way to remove the part of Voldy's soul without harming Harry? I think I asked this before but I can't remember what answer I got.

Yes.

See post number five, above.

It mentions "Bob."