Dumbledore Theory

but really...someone had to die...and JK picked dumbledore

Dumbledore probably died for a reason...we all just need to face the facts and move on...wait for the next book...

oh yea...the poly juice potion theory isnt tru...polyjuice potion only lasts an hour...they had the ceremony days later...sorry paddawan

Yeah but there must be other ways to change the appearence for longer. I know Dumbledore is probably dead i just have a hope that he will return. Another reason for life would be a horcrux but i dont see dumbledore as the type to have a horcrux.

What's with you guys?
It's all in the books.
And in my "Snape the Death Stopper" topic.
I gave an answer for every angle.
Dumbledore could so easily be alive that it would be insane to let himself die.
You really haven't read it, have you?
Read it, already.

Well, where is it at?

The begining of Snape the death stopper. Talks of the first book and how snape says you can stop death. I have read it . i agree thats how it could go but i like my polyjuice potion theory because it kills Snape.

I still think Dumbledore is dead, and I am sorry, but the real Snape almost has to be alive.

Snape may be alive and dumbledore may live as well. I WANT to belive that dumbledore LIVES. so i simply say he is alive. I dont know how but he still lives.

Dumbledore is not crazy and would not commit suicide.
I don't need to go into denial or wishful thinking.
It just doesn't make sense.

A well-ordered mind could accept the idea of his own death,
but would not plan it himself.
Faking his death would serve a purpose.
Actually killing himself would serve no purpose.

-- I just thought of another smart reason to fake his own death:
If Voldemort believes Dumbledore died to protect Harry...
Voldemort has seen that movie before and might not be as eager to attack.

Thats true and since he is really alive he will surprise voldemort when he turns up! Voldemort will be taken by surprise and could be destroyed.

Dumbledore is dead...he was weakened by the potion and snape came along and killed him...end of story...

dumbledore does not have a horcrux...he was not using the polyjuice potion...dumbledore was dumbledore and snape was snape....lets all accept it and move on