My Thoughts On Snape

I know there are a kajillion of these posts posted but I'm going to make it a kajillion and 1!lolz I just wanted to get my thoughts out there so that everyone would be able to read and respond...ok here I go...

Ok so Im re-reading HBP and well as I'm reading the 2nd chapter and gettin everything fresh in my mind again its leading me to believe that Dumbledore actually did tell snape to kill him and here is why I think so

Ok Narcissa goes to tell Snape "the plan" in hopes that he will be able to get Draco out of it. Now we all know that she says voldy told her that she was not to speak of "the plan" to anyone but she went to go tell Snape only to find that he knew about it already.....now think anout this 1.....Snape said that voldy knew that Draco would most likely fail in attemp to follow "the plan" thru and that Snape thought that voldy intended him to follow thru with it in the end....could it be possible that with this knowledge Snape went to discuss this matter with Dumbledore.....could it be possible that Dumbledore knew that Draco would not end up killing him and possibly made Snape make an unbreakable vow(like sum1 suggested b4) or sumthing else to make sure that snape would be the one to kill him so that it wouldn't be suspicious of him to let Dumbledore live when obviously Draco was ordered to kill him...and is it possible that when Dumbledore was pleading to Snape he was really asking Snape to do what he made him promise to do(like sum1 suggested also) which is y snape had that disgusted look on his face after he had done it....and also think about this 1 Narcissa says that no 1 had succeeded not even voldy which makes you believe they are all talking about Harry and now that I think of it that was probably a send off because of course everyone knows how voldy is always out to get harry in some way and maybe this was just voldies way of trying to weaken Harry by killing off sum1 like Dumbledore who was there to guide him and help him

And also I'd like to point out that voldy is a legillimense(im sorry I dont know how to spell it lolz) so this means that he can get into peoples thoughts...well Snape is an occluments(sorry don't know how to spell that 1 either lolz) so it could probably be very easy to clear his mind of all thought and emotions everytime he was in the presence of voldy so voldy wouldnt be able to penetrate his mind to see his true thoughts and feelings...so maybe Snape might really be good after all.....but hey these are just my thoughts

So yeah Im sorry I wrote abook but I just had to get all of my thoughts out lolz

Wow ! that's alot of typing. Those are some pretty good thoughts. I never thought about it like that before.

lolz yeah all these thoughts were just spilling outta my hea when I was reading lolz

I mean I dunno how much of it might be true but it seems somewhat logical 2 me lolz

yah that happens to me sometimes.

lolz yeah

ok, I think that your idea is pretty good. But I really wonder if Snape is bad or not. I mean, I hate Snape...and I figured since the beginning that he was bad. And in the end when he could have killed Harry and didn't...that was interesting. I know they said they were saying him for "The Dark Lord" but it would seem that nothing would make Vol. more happy than to see Harry dead, regardless of who killed him. But why wouldn't Dum. just let Draco fail? I mean, he will only cause problems in the end anyway. Also, they could have pretended he died and that Snape killed him. I am sure there is a way with magic that it could have been done. But...it is an interesting point you bring up. Maybe it is all fake on Snapes part.

And that's what makes me so cooky is because no1 knows 4 sure if snape is good or bad...but we will most def. find out his true colors come book 7......but i hear book seven wont be out until like 2008 or sumthing! Im not sure but i remember reading somewhere and thinking 'on no thats 2 long to wait!'

I completly agree with you. I believe that ultimately Snape is good. I'm not sure if he is carring out Dumbledores wishes but I am sure that what he is doing is for the greater good. I believe that Snape is going to surprise us in the end because one can only hope that Harry isn't alone in his fight after all.

well all i know is book 7 will most likely bring with it huge shocks and surprises!

snape is of course on the good side. in the 2nd chapter you can tell, i have read that chapter over, and over and over and over to find the ultimate conclusion. SNAPE IS GOOD. as much as i hate him he is on the good side. he lies if you look carefully to narcissa the whole time about why he hasn't yet killed harry. he told her that harry is not very strong at all and is actually below wizarding level. we all know that snape is lying about this because snape knows how powerful of a wizard that harry really is. snape knows about all the things harry has faced in his years at hogwarts.


what do you all think?