Twhsfec

You know what I just noticed? We're winning again, Shirli.

Team Snape members:
1. 100% of Gingobibble
2. 100% of Shirli
3. 100% of Luna Looney
4. 1/4 of Elmoro
5. The Best of Alo
6. The Best of Sky
7. At times- Rita
8. Some of Psyduck
9. 1/2 of Azra
10. 1/2 of Hermione_is_cool
11. 100% of Hedwig123
12. 100% of Teddylupin
13. 100% of Bezor
14. 100% of HP_Crazy
15. 100% of Sprout
16. 100% of Shaedum

Sixteen to fourteen! HA!

Snape was not loyal to Dumbledore he was loyal to the woman he killed. I am not saying Snape did not do anything that was key , I just do not view him as a hero. Everything he did was for selfish reasons, it was HIS love of Lily and even after she did not choose him he selfishly chose to worship her. If he truely loved her he would have listened to her wishes. Snape is key, but he was loyal only yo Lily and he was too ,loyal to her.

Carana2709 is also pro-Snape.
Please see alo's post of questions for the pro-Snape and anti-Snape brigade.
Forgive me if I got the numbers wrong - I'm not great with remembering numbers.

we are now at 17... can we get to 20....
come on team - we can do it!!!!!!!



GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO TEAM SNAPE!!!!

Team Snape members:
1. 100% of Gingobibble
2. 100% of Shirli
3. 100% of Luna Looney
4. 1/4 of Elmoro
5. The Best of Alo
6. The Best of Sky
7. At times- Rita
8. Some of Psyduck
9. 1/2 of Azra
10. 1/2 of Hermione_is_cool
11. 100% of Hedwig123
12. 100% of Teddylupin
13. 100% of Bezor
14. 100% of HP_Crazy
15. 100% of Sprout
16. 100% of Shaedum
17. 100% of Carana2709

GO TEAM SNAPE!!!!!!!!!!

Hmmm
Why are most of my friends in the love snape?
maybe it should be 1/2 of Seiyo for 18
* ponder ponder *

Think about it... we won't make you eat moss...

well the not eating moss part sure is good.
But I like Sara K. she is a good friend and I like Dobbin he is funny.
But the rest love snape...
And has snape ever done anything to redeem himself?

I don't think he ever has....

Seiyo- put yourself in Harry's place.
A man you hate for six years. Then you find out he risked his life on a daily basis for you, saved your life numerous times, helped you defeat the greatest Dark Wizard who ever was, and lied to said wizard constantly to protect you. What do you think of that man now?

I really agree. I think Harry would feel completely different about snape in the end if he had lived.I think Snape put his life out there repeatedly. And he didnt have to. I dont think he was a double spy or anything.I just wonder how hard it would be to be a death eater who is true to the order.
I mean look at luscios who tried everything he could and still failed.
A great wizzard snape was.

Personally I'd be stupid to forgive him.

I might have a little more respect for the man but I would never forgive him, I could never forgive him. Its like this, someone beat you to death numerous times and then years later you find out they were also protecting you, would you forgive for the burden they put on you?

Maybe I have to give this one more thought.
I'll be back with better opinion but for right now Hedwig I'm unsure is Harry should have forgiven him.