join DA

grin - welcome aboard dearie....

I have questions about the book and am curious about things that weren't resolved - but - I am not an author. I just don't think it right to criticise someone for doing something that I can't do.

imagine if - all the unanswered stuff was deliberately unanswered.
Imagine if JKR wanted us to use our own minds and create a solution that suits us.
Imagine if JKR wanted us to simply use our imaginations...

imagine if...

This book and the entire series are simply wonderful in allowing all of us to 'imagine if...'

I'd almost prefer to not know what happened 19 years after... but I do like the 'All was well' to end the book.

imagine if.... 19 years after the most significant battle of all times.... 'all was well'...

think about the significance of that statement. I think it's very powerful.
Simple and to the point.

I agree. I think the "all was well" ending was a nice way to wrap up the series. After all the terrible things that happened, the world came back to being a good place.
And I too like the fact that some things were left to our imaginations.

well "here i am" was too short to be aloud to be posted, so i was to make something up, an so there was pik puppins pup right there. born

How did you come up with the idea any way?

MEMEME! Pick ME!
PICK ME!
PICK ME!
PICK MEEE!!!!!!!!!
(How come I didn't think of this fabulous idea???)

Because secretly Hedwig you wish to join T.I.R.A.D.E!!!

NEVER!!!!!!




I repeat: PICK ME!!!

I thought there was a prevalence of 'anti-JKR' that was too harsh and unforgiving. I also like to take the 'path less travelled' and play 'devils advocate' on occasion. *grin*

TIRADE is a nice idea for people who hate the book.
I couldn't think of a word in support. so, I 'borrowed' DA - and tweaked it a little.

and - ok Hedwig - I pick you!!!
Well - to be honest, it's not even about me 'picking people'. If people want to chat about why they like the book - then I'm happy to talk to them about it. Just trying to restore the balance.

Yay! Now all I need are some people in G.O.I....
I loved the battle scene, except for the fact Remus and Tonks not getting a death scene. (That was NOT T.I.R.A.D.E. That is the one and only bit of the book you will ever hear me question.)
I loved the paragraph where Harry's running around, trying to reach Voldemort and watching what everyone else was doing. And I REALLY loved the fact that it was Ginny, Hermione, & Luna who were dueling Bellatrix before Molly stepped in.