Which Movies Stunk?

Agreed! We die-hard fans might be the only ones willing to sit through five hours, but we know lots of folks sit through 2.5 hour movies. Just divide them into two parts and tell the whole story!

HERE HERE pips and mc ....

I will go to a Harry Potter Marathon ANYDAY ...

But Ootp ...oh dear my least favourite.

oh ...and I HATED the talking shrunked heads on the knights bus , but I saw an interview with JK and she LOVEEDDDD them ?

Actually, I liked the shrunken head...
Shirli, you'd like him to if you saw the interviews from the third movie special features...

i wish, as you all already said, that they last longer...i hated that they cut and changed things!!!

okey i think that the goblet of fire was the worst they could of done the triwizard tounament so much better then they did. and more creature would of been nice considering there was none at all and goblet of fire was the book with a lot of creatures.
amd the order of the phinox was good but i have to say that it had some places that didnt work. and some stuff that could have been put in. i mean considering that the book is the longest she has wrote in the series u would think that it would be longer then the others but it was just the same length as the other movies.

On the length issue: When i first saw PoA, whenever I'd start ranting about it, my mom would look sympathetic(she also read HP. She originally got me hooked on it.) and say; "Longest of the first three books, shortest of the first three movies." And she was right about that!
Time limits are no excuse for lack of quality.
I want Chris Columbus back!!!!

I think that OOTP was by far the worst movie! They left out alot of very important parts from the book. I want to know how they are going to explain that Ron is in Quidditch in the HBP, when he tried out for the position of Keeper in the OOTP. And the fact that Hermione and Ron were made House Prefects in the 5th and will still be Prefects in the 6th. And what about when Harry, Fred and George were taken off of the Quidditch team. And what about the trip into Hogsmead with Harry and Cho. Isn't that where they kinda found out that they were not going to work out. It's also when they relieze that the Dementors were not out looking for all of those prisoners that broke out. And Hermione set up that interview with Rita for Luna's dads magazine. Which was all over Hogwarts dispite Umbridges constant vigalence. They just left out way way too much in OOTP!
Ok I've said my opinions outloud and now I'm fine.

i think the OOTP stunk, i know it was a lot to fit into a 2 hour movie but i still thought it was pretty rubbish compared to the book.

What's wrong with the rest?

I know it's not a rose of a film, but what is really so bad about it? I personally like the Goblet most, followed by the Order. A lot of details were left out, but essentially, all that was needed for the film was there.