Back From The Dead

I thought that it might be fun to see how many of us really think that either Sirius or Dumbledore are alive or how many think they are dead and how we expect to see them in book 7.

I personally think that they will both show up alive.

Hello again lol.. im not following you Honestly.. lol

anywho.. I think Dumbledore will be dead.. i know hard to think of.. JKR has already said he was..

Siruis will be alive.. LOL he has to be.. *gets on hands and knees.. PLEASE BE ALIVE*

Hi. Guess what? I made First Year. Yay. Must need around 25 posts I guess.

Explanation:: many of us expect to see Sirius alive in book7, and many of us expect to see Dumbledore alive. Then again many of us don't. There's another theory floating around that Dumbledore especially might come back to help Harry as a ghost, Obi-wan-kenobi style. I just thought we could tally up what we all think.

You're absolutely right Sirius will come back. No pleadin needed. He's going to use the two way mirror. I'm sure of it. As for Dumbledore, I don't know. I kinda tend to think that he's got a horcrux in his pheonix. But that's me. Even though JKR said he was dead, she might have been leading us on, getting us ready to drop the bomb sort of.

Vote, vote, and let me know if you think any of these two make it back and how.

I don't know if either would be alive. I believe that in a way (possibly a portrait) Dumbledore will be there but Sirius I'm not really sure about. If Sirius is not dead then how did Harry inherit No. 12 Grimmwauld Place. It would be wonderful if Sirius did come back though, I was so happy when he appeared in the 3ird book. But I'm really not sure on the matter, I can't want for Deathly Hallows to come out!

they are both dead.