Movie Mistakes

Lumos, thanks.
That's funny though. I hate it when I catch flaws because then I feel like its less perfect then it was.
...Though they usually stay god movies. Hey, anyone notice in the "two towers," when the Horsemen attack the Uruk-Hai, poor Pippin is struggling to get away, and his hands are bound, THEN when the horse is about to stomp on him, his hands are untied? That REALLY bothers me, everytime I watch it, though I do my best to ignore it.

Perfect isn't nearly as interesting as imperfect.

me to ... but i only watched some of them a once
i don't watch the movies cause the books are always better...... then i dont reread the books (usualy/at least i used to) because it takes away from the whole story... ill prefer to read them again after i read all of the books

i cant beleve there are only 7!

after i finishes the 5th book i cried

wow i can't believe dudley mouthed that lol thats funny

[who cares

And a howdy-do to you, too.
You dig up a thread that is almost a year old and ask, "who cares"?

Join us in something more recent!
So, do you believe Dumbledore is dead or alive?

And a howdy-do to you, too.
You dig up a thread that is almost a year old and ask, "who cares"?

Join us in something more recent!
So, do you believe Dumbledore is dead or alive?
[/b][/quote]


Well...if your asking in a genaral sense...I'd say he's dead! I can't give you any reasoning cause I don' t have any...I just have a feeling JK Rowling wouldn't do that to her fans...but then again who knows?

That's cool to find out all the mistakes they've made!

Ok...here's some more mistakes I copied and pasted from another site!

*
There is a scene where Harry is holding the letter from Sirius and we can hear Sirius's voice reading the letter. The words on the letter are different from the words we hear Sirius reading. Particularly the end where Sirius says, "P.S. The bird bites" the letter says, "By the way, the bird bites."


* When Fred or George passes the note to Ron during the study hall, the style of writing on the note changes between shots. The number of lines it took to write the sentence changes from four to three.


* After Harry overhears the conversation between Snape and Karkaroff, Snape holds up the small glass bottle of Veritaserum while he accuses Harry of stealing from his store of ingredients. The way Snape holds the bottle repeatedly differs between the close-ups facing Harry and close-ups facing Snape.


* When Fred and George pass Ron the note in the Great Hall encouraging him get a date before all the good ones are gone, the writing is on the top of the page. When Ron reads the note, it appears that the writing is a bit lower on the sheet of paper.


* After Harry comes out of the pensieve, Dumbledore stares straight ahead while he is talking, as if Harry is clear across the room, rather than looking directly at Harry. In the next shot, however, Dumbledore's body is turned slightly, and he's leaning down, looking directly at Harry, yet no time has passed







Mistakes in Harry Potter and the Philosophers Stone -


* The mechanism which makes the Quidditch box shake can be seen when the box falls over.


* There is a scene where Harry is holding the letter from Sirius and we can hear Sirius's voice reading the letter. The words on the letter are different from the words we hear Sirius reading. Particularly the end where Sirius says, "P.S. The bird bites" the letter says, "By the way, the bird bites."


* During the train journey, Ron's hair is parted in several different places.


* On the train scene, the same hill as well as lake (as seen by the waves in the middle of the water) are seen multiple times.


* At Halloween, Dumbledore announces for the teachers to follow him to the dungeon to find the troll. The next shot is of McGonagall and in front of her you can see the strings holding up the "floating" candles.







Mistakes in Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets -


* In the Quidditch scene, Harry breaks his right arm, but as he sits up after he falls off his broom, he leans directly on it.


* In the first film, we see that Susan Bones (the red haired girl) is sorted into Hufflepuff, however throughout the Chamber of Secrets, Susan not only has her classes with the Gryffindors BUT is also wearing a Gryffindor tie.


* In the scene where the Chamber finally opens, we first see Harry, Ron and Professor Lockhart from the front, and Harry and Ron are slightly behind Lockhart, and in a position to threaten and guard him. When you next see them a moment later from behind, Lockhart is behind them and they are in no position to guard him.


* When Harry first hears the whispering voice and is walking down the hallway feeling the wall as the voice gets louder. Notice he has a round red mark on the back of his right hand. In the next shot it's gone.


* When Lockhart falls down the hole into the Chamber of Secrets, we hear him hit the ground a second or two later. When Ron and Harry jump down, not only do they take longer to get down, they also slide down the pipe, rather than fall straight down.






Mistakes in Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban -


* When Harry is coming up from the trapdoor in cellar in Honeydukes, a crew member is visible just underneath Harry, giving him a push upwards.


* During the dinner scene at the Dursleys, Dudley is shown in a close-up watching a game-show where a young woman is putting on large headphones. But when the shot returns to the whole room, you can see the girl on the TV putting on the headphones all over again. .


* In the scene when all the kids are leaving for Hogsmeade, you can see that Harry's face is pressed against the inside of the big clock tower overlooking the entrance to Hogwarts. Later on in the movie, when Harry and Hermione are back in time, the camera zooms through the same clock and you can see that the back is covered by lots of equipment. How did Harry have his face pressed against the glass?.


* When Harry goes back to Hogwarts and they stand before the Fat Lady portrait she refuses to let them in because she's trying to show them she can break a glass with her voice. When she cannot she smashes it upon a brick wall behind her right shoulder. Later in the movie after the students gather around the Fat Lady's painting after it's slashed the wall is missing..


* The first stone Hermione throws into Hagrid's hut changes size. It is much larger when she picks it up the first time than when she is seen throwing it later in the movie.

This isn't A HP glich, it's a charmed glich. It's about the episode where the monkey takes Pheobe's hearing, Paige's voice, and Piper's sight. The lady helping the demond puts Leo in a water filled container so he can't orb, when Piper gets him out you can see dry spots on his shirt.
Oh and DD is alive it's in my sigy as you can see. And no matter how much you bicker with me I won't change my mind. That's how stubborn I am.

Those movies are SO BAD!
And you know the next ones are not going to improve.
Why does JKR let these idiots continue to ruin them?
I'm sure someone will do them over eventually,
but I don't want to wait 20 or 30 years for that.
Why can't they just... I don't know... get a brain?

On J.K.'s website she seemed pretty happy with the movies. I mean she understood that some things couldn't be changed. But the stuff she let slide by were obvious mistakes. (But I probably wouldn't see them for one I don't zone in on detail. And I need new glasses, everything is starting to be blury. But does my dad listen to me nooooo. Let my eyesight continue to fail me. Anyway enough of my problems.)