Did U See The Movie?

yeah, i would hav to vote a 8

it was not the way i hoped it would be but it was pretty good and it could have been better

*prepares for outraged fans* I'd give it a 6 out of 10. maybe.

When POA movie began I loved the Inflatable Large Marge and the Knight Bus and the Shrunken Head and Stan Shunpike, the conductor and Ernie, the bus driver and I gave the movie a 10.

I did not, DO NOT like the new actor playing Dumbledore. Minus 1.

I did not, DO NOT like the Time Turner sequence when the movie re-played the same scenes I'd already seen. Minus 2.



The Sorcerer's Stone gets a 10.
The Chamber of Secrets gets a 10.
Prisoner of Azkaban gets a 7.

I agree with KaraC. POA left something to be desired.

Yes! Zonko, at least somebody understands me.
Though hold on for a quick second. True, it was a little old when they had to show the sequence twice, but that's exactly what happened in the book, they had to put it in.
To comfort you though, if I had been director, I would've made it so interesting, it'd be your favorite part in the movie. I think.
My favorite movie of the three was the second. the first one, I personally had a difficult time finding excitment and emotion until the Quidditch scene, it was awesome there on.

Karac you apsalutely correct, I think alfonso put more enfoses on action or rather the fluff then he did on the emotions which you could call the meat and potatoes. Wow now I am hungry.

Zonko I would agree with you grade but I liked the time sequence, because it was acually true to the book, I would how ever mark it down for the ending, it should have ended at least with sirus's letter not an 1980's freeze frame.

Are you all completely insane who cares if dumbledore slaps rons leg, they have a new actor for him so of coarse hes not going to act completely the same.

As for the dementors being dressed the way they were thats the way they were described in the book so of coarse their going to be animated that way.

Hermoine had every right to slap the sh** out draco hes been giving her crap for the last 3 years and i just think you were all being too critical. It was a harry potter movie he was hot hermoine kicked butt and it doesnt deviate from the book too much so if you didnt like the movie you probably didnt really like to book to begin with.

I loved watching Hermione punch out Draco Malfoy. That was excellent! What a witch! I hope she does it again some time.

I voted that I hated it, which isn't true, but it's closer to the mark than saying I loved it. Like I've said in the past, the director tried to cram WAY TOO MUCH in such a short time. He should've left more out, or made the movie longer. Gads!

i loved it its like the movie told its own story which is not exactly a good thing but it was ok. i did like the secene where harry had the invisible cloak on and he picked on malfoy crabbe and goyle. i thought that was funny but in the book it was different so idon't know i really enjoyed it but i guess some ppl think differently