The Movies

I had forgotten St Mungos -- I thought about it during the movie though when they had that silly little line where Neville was telling Harry about his parents.

In the third book isn't Harry suppose to be older than Hermione because she says in the third one that her birthday is the first day of September yet in the sixth book Hermione is older than Harry because she takes the Apparition test before Harry with Ron. Didn't any1 notice that because that was what was really bugging me in the sixth book when I was reading it.

what do you imagine peeves to be...i picture slimer from the Ghostbusters movies

hermione turns 14 in september, but harry doesn't until the following summer

yes when you compare the movie to the book it comes up quite short, but when you compare the movie to other movies like it or other harry potter movies it is a great movie...the movies are for the people too lazy to read the books...and me cause i love the movies an the books

So how come she is just took the Apparition test in the 6th year. I thought you are suppose to take the test when you turn 17 or was it 16.

i agree.

The movies are a nice extension of the books -- certainly NOT a replacement. I can't imagine watching the movies without reading the books. BUT that's exactly what my sons do *hanging head in shame*

i hated that when harry got the fire bolt it was taken away and he does doing magic! talk about hello folow the darn book what is with dierecters huh?

What bugs me about the movies is that they always leave out the motivation. The plot jumps in certain places because the things that lead up to it has been taken out. It also others me that people who have watched the movies , think they know everythng about the books. its frustating!! The most inaccurate movie, I think is the Goblet of fire. Ther are so many things which were left ourt or changed, its quire funny. The part where Neville gives Harry the Gillyweed was by far the most changed part. What do you think was the biggest changes in the moves from the books???