Poa: What Would You Have Added?

Yep. The movies really stink.
If we wrote a book about all of the things wrong with them,
it would probably be longer than the Half-Blood Prince.

I hate to give the movie people any credit at all, but that was one of the few things they got right. In the book, Lupin explained why his friends could keep him company as animals, and that "A warewolf is only a danger to people."

how did they get that right when he bit or scratched sirius when he was a dog? (though he was trying to keep lupin away from snape harry hermione and ron)
and dont you think they did some what of a good job setting the scene of hogwarts and the animation for the hippogriff? jk is helping them in the processes. (my sister reminds me of that all the time when i point out a mistake) she even said herself she wished she would have thought of the shrunken head in the knight bus, thats just an example. they do make mistakes, some much bigger then others, though i can understand one being so faithful to the book that the movies almost ruin it but you have to keep an open mind the book is just a guide for the movie not the screen play and script. i believe that the magic in the books is there in all the movies as well, mistakes or not.

I would have liked to see him staying the two weeks in the Leaky Cauldron too, plus looking longingly at the Firebolt and having his icecream sundaes at Fortescue's.

I also thought the third movie was rushed. If I hadn't read the book I wouldn't have got what was happening in it. I think the bit at the end in the Shrieking shack should have given a bit more information. Or if not then, but at a different time. Plus, more Quidditch and a broom for Christmas would have been good.

I hated how they moved the broom for Christmas to the broom at the end of hte school year. I mean we totally missed out on the fight between Harry and Hermione. And on the frustration Harry felt at not getting his broom, ya kno.

QUIDDITCH CUP!!!