What's your opinion on 5th movie?

I personally think the fifth movie could have been better, I love it don't get me wrong, but it seemed like it wasn't complete, like it was missing something. Also I thought it was a little choppy but maybe that's just me. Once again I still love the movie as well as the previous 4.

Post your opinions so I can see whether or not I'm crazy

I didn't like it...

I must say I was disapointed in that they left out so much of the book. Yes, I still bought it and have watch it several times; however, I really think that they should have kept in the fact that Ron and Hermione were prefects. Ron trying out for Quidditch and making the team. And several other parts that I think were needed in the movie.

You're right, it was very choppy, and they changed waaaayyy too many things, and left out too much, and they didn't put that it was ALL KREACHER'S FAULT that Sirius died!!! Although, we can't blame Kreacher, he didn't know what he was doing, but I think it's important to the plot.

If you don't compare it to the book, then it was a great movie, but in comparison...it's just not, although I did like it.

I agree. (my sister & I are watching it on HBO right now) For one, it left out a lot of things (like Ron & Hermione being prefects, & Ron making the quidditch team), some of which are actually important to the story, like when they were cleaning up in Grimmauld Place & happened upon the locket. They left out Mundungus Fletcher & Peeves completely, they didn't introduce Tonks to the watchers of the movie (& my sister wouldn't quit asking me "who's that?"), &, most importantly, they've left out the fake galleons & the mirror that Sirius gave Harry. They both become very important in the last book. Also, they didn't tell the whole prophesy like in the book.

I loved the fight scenes, finally they did them some justice. I was sad that they left out so much of the story though. They needed more Sirius!

The main problem with this movie was the pace it goes at. It is so fast that one minute you are barely scratchibng the surface of a scene and then you are put into a new scene with no transition.

It was okay but you guys are right, they left too many good parts out.