Where Is Sirius

I think Sirius is dead--behind the veil. I still think Harry or Dumbledore could have used the Time Turner to save his life. Why didn't they?

Harry still has pieces of the mirror Sirius gave him. Remember Harry was supposed to look into it to talk to Sirius. I wonder if Sirius will come back to talk to Harry through the mirror later on, when Harry needs him the most.

Dumbledore said that help would always be given at Hogwarts if anyone asked for it. Maybe Harry just needs to look in the mirror and ask Sirius for his help.

Whaddya think?

I cannot say i agree completly with any of yall, I believe the veil is a portal if you will to sort of a witch heaven , I think harry needs to start thinking outside the box, sirus gave harry a mirror to contact him hmmm... harry also saw his parents in a mirror once.... perhaps finding the mirror harry used to retrieve the sorcerers stone with the mirror from siris will bring about a new portal in which harry can retrieve spirits from the other side, in which case i know of 3 i hope he retrieves....

I feel Harry is going to loose him control, and that this "ANGER" is going to give him the courage and the plain out state of mine to rid himself and the world of voldamort forever.... I believe Harry hasnt unleashed pure rage yet, and once he does dumbledore wont be the only wizard voldamort need fear!!

You're right. Harry is primed to explode now that he figures he is marked for final battle with Voldemort. Both Harry and Dumbledore believe the prophecy refers to Harry.

But don't forget about Neville who acts like a doofus most of the time. He could be a sleeper. The prophecy refers to a child born in July. Both Neville and Harry were born in July. Harry is clearly marked by Voldemort--the scar on his forehead--when his parents were killed. Neville's parents were tortured into insanity by Beatrix Le Strange, Death Eater. I wonder if Neville was marked because of this and we just don't know about it yet. Anyway just keep Neville in mind when you think about the outcome.

well i dont personally think hes dead . he just cant be . but i think one way or onother harry is going to do something about it . and he will turn up in another book. i bet he will. even dow some people think hes dead. that my opinion what do u think.

Voldemort is definitely not dead. In Book 5, he acquired a body and is able to touch Harry without turning into mattress stuffing. Voldemort also got his wand back. I wonder where that's been all this time. So Voldemort is going to be as powerful as he ever was.

i think that harry is going to go crazy with sadness, and try to figure out a way to get through the veil.

Page 806 Order of the Phoenix. Harry wants to follow Sirius just after he falls into the veiled doorway. Lupin holds him back and tells him there is nothing he can do. Lupin says Sirius is gone. However, I agree that Sirius Black left behind too much unfinished business with Harry. He has got to come back. I think the only question is HOW?

We do know that his death spirit is in Bellatrix LeStrange's wand. So if Harry meets up with her, Sirius will come to his aid. There is still the business with the mirror. Harry has yet to talk to Sirius in the broken mirror at the bottom of his trunk. JKR wouldn't put that much dead-end detail into one of her books. She's a very busy woman.

So don't worry. Odds are 99.9% that Sirius will return!

this sounds stupid. the fifth book is entitaled" harry potter and the half blood prince" . well i found out on a web site the half blood prince isnt harry or voldamort! well i think the half blood prince is none other then neville longbottom!! stupid huh!! well with harry potter u never kno!!! :P

i meant sixth book!!

There is no such thing as a stupid guess because, guess what? We're ALL guessing. So hah, you are one of us! We are Potterheads and proud of it!

The HBP is supposed to be a surprise so you want to pic a long shot. Neville is a long shot for the title. My pick is Gilderoy Lockhart. I'll bet 3 Knuts that he is the HBP.