heres a question

the new spells harry used in the sixth book from the half bllod prince, do you agree with hermione that the spells were crazy and shouldnt be used or do u think that some should u but not all like the one harry used on draco in the bathroom should not be used. i am intrested to hear every bodies thoughts on this.

i think that if i had the book that i would probably use every spell that was in that book. Especially if someone was trying to use an unforgivable curse on me

i didnt anderstand the question .. can y re-write it

Come again???

Morally, I think that every spell should be used with caution and care as to when and where it is called for. There are some really bad spells and the fact that they exist is scary, but they should be know to all who might encouter them. So that a counter spell can be intreduced or if needed to use the orginal to defend yourself, only if nessicary. But then that is why there is a school and family to teach young ones the difference and the dangers in casting spells.

I agree, but my curiosity would win! I think that you must know what you're doing and not waving your wand just for kiks...
Altough Harry did it by instinct, he didn't mean to hurt raco the way that he did... You should be carefull with books like Hermione says

I dont blame Harry for trying out the spells.
After all the success he was having in Potions from using the book, of course he would try out the spells....

Well, obviously using an unknown spell is like eating an unknown plant - there are unknown consequences. I think using it (or eating it) shows how reckless or desperate you are.

Every spell and every spell useage is in context. Certainly spells like the Unforgiveables shouldn't be prevalent, but I don't think Sectumsempra(sp?) is quite up to that level... I think it's more borderline dark but definitely far from the worst that needs to be completely outlawed. Of course, as with all undocumented offensive spells, it's an "approach with caution" label.

The Half-Blood Prince's other spells are mostly harmless, I would think. There isn't a concrete reason they shouldn't be used, and some like "Muffalito" are definitely useful. Sure, they could probably be turned to harmful intent, but then so can any spell- Wingardium Leviosa can go from first-year Hovering Charm to fatal if used in the wrong way (Off a cliff? What about the troll? What if that was a person the the club was a much larger object?) :/

i think hermione was right!