Mcgonagall's Loyalties

You're right - she's not like Snape... because Snape isn't bad! Snape is actually on the good side, while McGonagall is actually a Death Eater. Therefore they are nothing alike, you are quite right in that aspect.

Are you two sure of that ?
I mean , Snape still looks like a death eater since he killed Dumbledore in the sixth ,
and all of us wouldn't know the truth until the final one comes out .

Alright , I have to confess that I've always liked McGonagall much more than Snape ,
though the " Minerva is evil " theory is quite interesting and couldn't be impossible .
But we could thought that McGonagall 's just sometimes " moody " when she sobs .

Yes, i think that this theory is pretty cool, but false. I think that McGonagall may just be imbarassed by a laugh or something, and that is why she doesn't smile or something.


Ok, OK that theory is about as whack as mine. lol, no offense. :P

That is retarded. McGnagall is the only one that stands up for harry win Umdrige says he cant be an Auror.
Not only that but if she is a death eater and she wants to get Harry to Voldormort why did she save him from getting expelled so many times.RETARDED

Yes, McGonagall stands up for Harry when Umbridge says he can't be an Auror - but that could just be because she hates Umbridge. Think about it - Who was the first person to tell Harry he should be an auror? The Fake Moody - aka Barty Crouch jr. aka the Dark Lord's most loyal servant!! So really her sticking up for Harry shows nothing.

well that is true. If that was the only time that she stood up for Harry then it would be a viable thery. But no she helped Harry out more than that. In the first book she could or should have expelled Harry when he was flying.
I am sure there are others but i cant think about them at the moment.

who ever thinks mcgonnagall's evil, is truly wrong!! well, i cant be completly sure of course, but still!! i mean, shes the new head master!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
also, dumbledor trusted her, and you could go into him trusting snape...and look what happened!!!but i still belive snape is good!!!snape is still on the good side(i think) does anyone agree???

Yes and No. i came to the theory that Snape must have an Unbreakable vow on him, Becuae he has never disobeyed the Headmaster, always done what he sais even when he didn;t like it. And becuase of this...i think to a certain degree he's bad. Why else would he have a vow on him. But he theory also stiks up for him. If he did/does have an Unbreakable Vow on him...thn he had no choice but to "kill" Dumbledore. Becuae the book shows that Dubledore gave him a direct order at least.

honestly there is no reasonable evidence that proves that McGonnal is evil the sings all point the other way