Should the "Dumbledore Lives" debate continue?

Our own "Aberforth" started "The Dumbledore Lives Club" back in June of 2006.
The Dumbledore Lives! Club
(The debate pretty much ended with the release of The Deathly Hallows.)

Then he started the "The Dumbledore Lives Club Members List" in December of 2006.
The Dumbledore Lives Club Members List
That thread is (a) just a list and (b) a little piece of HPC history. It was not a place to debate.

I'm moving recent posts that don't really fit to this new thread.

dd is dead, even how great he was.....greater men died..

I think he is dead. But like when headless nick is explaining to Harry thatr you choose to stick around and be a ghost I think dumbledore is really in his own place he chose. I mean didnt he talk to snape threw his picture at Hogwarts? I just think he choose his own place to go like the ghosts do.

Cleaning up in "Should the Dumbledore Lives debate continue?"

I deleted the first posts in from Sara, Luna, Shirli, Rita and Hermie because they misunderstood the purpose of the thread while it was still under construction.

I moved posts from Azra, Psyduck, Shaedum, Hermie, Shirli to the new thread in Hogsmeade, "What did she do NOW?" because they still were off-topic.

Moved posts from Shirli, Godrichallowgirl, Psyduck to "This Site is Tooooooo Slow" (Madam Pomphrey's forum) because they changed the topic again.

In "Notes & Tips for Newbies" (Hogwarts Express forum) Post # 21 is about "What happened to my shouts?"
Shaedum, Shirli, Luna, Gingo, *Love-Potter* and I got side-tracked on this topic, so I consolidated those thoughts in a place where they might be helpful.

i think that dumbledore is dead. not in our memory though...how do they say it?..."Always Blessings, Never Losses"...doest that makes any sense? probably not..

i'm sorry but every one knows that dumbledore does not live and i think we need 2 get over that and MOVE ON!

why does some say that he is still alive? spiritually then?

Its all becaus of the Dh talk*spoiler* because dumbledore is talking to harry nad is very much alive...again though I think he has just chose his place.

agreed. there is no debate to be had. If you examine the text, you will see that he is dead.
ahem.

I am officialy joining you!