Quote:
Sorry but I'm not conviced by that website. There are some interesting things on it but at the end of the day it's just guessing. I've just read book 6 again and i've pretty much accepted he's dead, although the Horcrux theory is interesting. Snape did kill Dumbledore. but if he does have a Horcrux then he could be resurrected by it. Sorry Aberthorth, but the challenge starts now!
[/b]
|
First of all, WE ARE ALL JUST GUESSING! Everyone but JK is guessing! But, thats the fun of it!
Another interesting tidbit is that JK has said that she monitors the internet a little and if she sees that people are going WAY off base on an issue she'll redirect them. I have yet to see any form of redirection on this issue and its been out there since the 6th book came out! Now, I'm not trying to say that means we're right about this but at least we can have comfort in the fact that we're not WAY off base either!
My main point for posting is this, Dumbledore would not be such an evil person to kill someone to make himself a Horcrux! Now if he just happened to HAVE to kill someone like that first evil sorcerer what was his name? The one talked about on the Chocolate Frog cards? Maybe he used the opportunity then but I seriouly doubt it! Dumbledore didn't even know that Tom Riddle would become Voldemort then, so why would he? He wasn't even SURE until Harry gave him Slughorn's memory! And like I said he would never just kill someone to make a Horcrux. Seeing as how the only way explained thus far to split the soul and make a Horcrux is to kill someone I don't see that as a possibility, on the other hand, Snape says he can "Even put a stopper in Death!" I know you've heard that phrase a million times but it fits doesn't it, and JK loves to plant clues as we all know!
Space Invaders
Linear Mode
