Oddities And Coincidences In The Books

Red and Green?
What?

[color=#FF0000]Red and Green?
What?
[/b][/quote]


um ..... didn't you mention this in your theory?
what do you mean by " What " ?

Red and Green?
What?
[/quote]


um ..... didn't you mention this in your theory?
what do you mean by " What " ?
[/quote]

there is a section in the coincidences written by phoenixdumbledore about the colors red and green. i just read that post, and it's in the 13th paragraph. i also realized i made my username RitaSkeeter and you already had it. i'm sorry! i wanted to change it but i don't think i can.

I've known the difference between the Skeeters all along. One spaces the middle and the other is the new copycat. Just kidding. I don't think there is any reason to change anyone's name. People that read Harry Potter are on the more intelligent side. They'll catch on like I did.

Somthing that i thought was odd was when DD was comforting Hagrid in GOF he talked about his brother got in trouble for what sounded like turning a goat in to a woman

Oh, he did not either.
I can't find the book right now, but
It was just something vague about improper charms.
Somebody, get out the book quick and kill this one.

Ha ha . That's ok : )

you mabe in love w Aberforth but it clearl states on page 454 and i qoute

"My own brother Aberforth was prosecuted for practing anappropriate charms on a goat. It was all over the papers but did Aberforth hide?NO, he did not he held his hesd high and went about his business as uaual!
of corse I'm not entirely sure that he can read so that may not have been bravery.'
you know what that sounds like to me.
It sounds like he was making with a goat read it for your self Aberforth sounds like a bumpkin and those bumpkins do wierd things W/O magic think what they would do w magic
sorry to point out the wiredness of the book is that not what i was told to do

Get your mind out of the gutter.
It is simply not there.
It's a children's book.
And JKR said in an interview that it's nothing.

http://www.leakylounge.com/lofiversi...hp/t34788.html (half-way down the page)

Q: What on earth was Aberforth Dumbledore doing with those goats?
[Big laughs from all]
JKR: Your guess is as good as mine! [Evil laugh!]

right she basicaly confirmed what i said and only an adult mind would be able to under stand what i was saying.