buffy:but even if snape does payback harry do you think will "dock" so low as to take harry in no snape has to much hate in him.he does not hate harry but generates his hate for harry's dad towards harry and i don't think he will softn up i'm thinking he thinks he will lose his dignity or something.anyway i'm kind of that way also but when i'm writing essays for school i like to kill my characters.but i basically enjoy a happy ending but why does this have to end happily.because poeple want it that way.but harry does have a 50/50 chance of survivng this and he should try to boost his odds instead of gtting into tantrums and stuff.and snape paying back with his life does seem like a nice option or maybe even teaching him and preparing him for his battle.

i've got a question.why do you think dumbledore does not want to give snape the defence against the dark arts position?does anyone have anyidea?