Lupin should have known that Peter was alive and well and on the Hogwarts grounds at that very moment.
You should always read the first post, at the very least.
Quote:
Originally Posted by DublinDolly  In PoA, when Ron, Hermione and Harry were getting pulled into the Whomping Willow, Luipin saw them. But if he Saw them, then Lupin would have seen Buckbeak hiding in the Forrest with Harry and Hermione from 3 hours away, and would have known he was alive. Right?... |
If that doesn't make it clear, keep reading. In this case, down to post #5.
Quote:
Originally Posted by DublinDolly If he saw them walking out of Hagrid's with Peter, then he would have HAD to see the 3 little names above the piece of forest near the ones with Scabbers. It would have caught his attention, as they would have been out in the grounds when they should have been in their Common Room. |