Re: james saving snape What we know is that: -Sirius told Snape how to get to the Shrieking Shack. -Snape, of course, tried it, and was pulled back by James before he could be killed by Remus, but not before seeing enough to realize Remus was a werewolf. -Snape owes James a life debt as a result. -Sirius was only (comparitively) lightly punished for seriously endangering the lives of his fellow classmates. (And that this is one of the reasons Snape hates Sirius.) -Snape is sworn to secrecy on the subject of Remus' lycanthropy. We don't know: -Why Sirius was stupid enough to essentially attempt to murder Snape and seriously harm Remus (if only emotionally. No one wants to be used as a tool to kill.) -Exactly what happened in the tunnel on the night of the full moon. -What their punishments were. -How the incident effected the relationships between Snape and the other Maruaders/Lily. (Did Snape hate James because he thought James knew about the "prank"? Remus? Lily?) -The nature of the life-debt. -How it effects Snape as a person. |