09-15-2007, 09:45 AM
|
 | Caretaker | | Join Date: Jul 2007
Rating:
Posts: 1,733
| |
 Re: G.o.i.
Ah, it's good to see that even while I was on my forced hiatus, HPC remains steady. Ranty hedwig: check! Quirky Alo: check! Historical-observant-arguements-you-can't-disagree-with-without-sounding-heartless-Gingo: check! Sarcastically-logical Psy: check! TIRADE Becca: check! (Yes!  ) Oh, and, of course: Punctuation-lacking-repetitive-ekin: check. :/ hedwig-playing-the-"i'm-twelve-and-a-half"-card: check! XD Anyway: Dumbledore I'm neutral on, but really, I'm not sure this one is worth making a club over. DA I can understand, even as comic relief, but GOI- well, 1)needs a better name, and 2)shows that Feathers is really, really, really bored. I don't know if I would really say he's still alive, after DH, BUT I do agree that him actually being alive had a lot of possibilities that weren't used to their real potential. I think that an ending can be difficult to write- but that does not justify completely botching it up. If the "journey" is done so well, than at LEAST have a neutrally done ending. It's doesn't have to take an encore, but running of the stage and tripping over itself is not the way to go either, ESPECIALLY after a good performance. -Supporting Becca, still, on the count that DH was poorly written.
Last edited by teddylupin : 09-29-2007 at 11:15 PM.
|