I thought there was a prevalence of 'anti-JKR' that was too harsh and unforgiving. I also like to take the 'path less travelled' and play 'devils advocate' on occasion. *grin*

TIRADE is a nice idea for people who hate the book.
I couldn't think of a word in support. so, I 'borrowed' DA - and tweaked it a little.

and - ok Hedwig - I pick you!!!
Well - to be honest, it's not even about me 'picking people'. If people want to chat about why they like the book - then I'm happy to talk to them about it. Just trying to restore the balance.