Quote:
Originally Posted by amm  well i suppose if you were going to get technical. but the fractions are just for the purpose of explaining.
considering horruxes were invented by JK, i would think its safe to say that anyone could be right, maybe one horcrux did have 'bigger chards'.
the bottom line is that everyone basically agrees on the same theory. |
I can't believe that JK meant that the parts of the soul have any specific size. We are not talking about anything material, and I think JK has made that clear before.
I think she wanted to tell us, that Voldemort has damaged himself in an unnatural way. And that there is no way back for him. He is no human beeing any longer.
The soul is something abstract, and normally you can not split it. You can not take a part away, like cutting your arm off your body, or so.
Dumbledore even wanted to belive that Grindelwald had some regretts before he died. And I think that was the reason he did not kill Grindelwald.
He believed in the good in everyone until his death. But because of the Horcruxes he could not believe in the good in Voldemort.