Quote:
Originally Posted by teddylupin  I've never really liked the movies, but then in comparison to the book version, they are almost always (PJ's LOTR aside) much more dissapointing.
I thought they were all okay, that they were not horrible, as far as movies go, but that they also could have done better, especially for OotP. Some of the earlier years were good, but obviously they had less material they had to fit in, so it was easier. |
I continue to think that the movies are very good. I suppose my expectations have never been that high and possibly my memory is so poor that I have usually forgotten almost the entire book by the time the movie arrives. It's true that they are not as satisfying or rich but I still feel that they have a lot of charm.
Again, I just have such a long history of loving books and being disappointed in movies, that I don't need to get so much from the movies.