Originally Posted by Psyduck

That Septun-whatever spell caused both George's injury and Malfoy's injury in HBP. Shape cured Malfoy's pretty little face. It can be done. Was Snape the only wizard on the planet with such knowledge?

Originally Posted by mcdirector

I'm sure not -- there was also intent involved -- Harry wasn't a dark magic type. I wonder if that played into it.

Originally Posted by alohamora

I think Psyduck has a point lol. Your theory on intent has a hole in it. Snape was not aiming for George..if I read the book right.

Originally Posted by mcdirector

I'm sure most of my theories are full of holes. I don't mean for them to be, but . . .

Originally Posted by alohamora

Join the holey club then. I nominate George as founder .. myself Chairperson and you as VP.