Quote:
Originally Posted by amm  ...Also I think Dumbeldore... there is I think a chance that he could not be entirely 'dead'... I am also lead to think this because when harry has the stone, there are only 4 people who return to see him, lily, james, lupin and sirius, I am sure if harry had the choice he would have wanted to see dumbeldore.
"so why would you take the stone?" Ron asked him.
"Well if you could bring people back, we could have Sirius, Mad-Eye...Dumbeldore.. my parents"
perhaps if dumbeldore wasn't technically dead, he would have returned... |
So much left unanswered. Could JKR be... might she have all along been planning an eighth book, but wants us to believe certain things for the moment?
Quote:
Originally Posted by amm ...but i am probably looking too far into it! |
Most likely. If wishes were horses...