Quote:
Originally Posted by Aberforth  But this still puts him in the position of potentially haveing to kill Dumbledore. Why would he do that if he were good? |
When you finish the book you see that he had the best reason in the world to kill Dumbledore, he had promised AD that he would--giving AD the choice of WHEN and HOW he wanted to die rather than suffering from the curse. I felt badly for Snape. He got a bad deal all around. AHacker