Quote:
I saw someone on these boards say they thought Harry was a Horcrux. While I was reading I thought that also. Do you think the green light in the scene where Voldemort tries to kill Harry is the spell to make Harry a Horcrux? If this is a plausible theory then, in the end Harry must die! Do you think JK would do that to us? We've suffered so much already. 
I can't decide if I think Harry is or isn't a Horcrux. If he is Voldemort wouldn't want him dead now would he? How does the soul get out of a Horcruz?
[/b]
|
I've seen this Harry-is-a-Horcrux theory is getting really popular isn't it?Well...intriguing maybe , but I don't think so.You see , Voldie heard about the profecy and went to the Potters' house to kill him(according to the profecy Harry is a real threat 4 him, right) ?Think it's quite clear in all books Voldie did want to kill Harry (and still does )and he tried to .Otherwise , if he hadn't tried the Avada Kadavra against Harry ,the curse wouldn't have turned back and killed him.So , why would he make a Horcrux only to destroy it right aftrewards ?I thougt Voldie is a clever guy...Any convincing?