Quote:
Harry's Secret Brother,
That's a really good theory! Really good! One of the better explanations of the "Severus please" line that I've heard.
But . . .
If Dumbledore was realizing at that moment that he had misplaced his trust in Snape then how does the Snape/Dumbledore conversation that Hagrid overheard fit into your theory? If I remember correctly, Snape was telling Dumbledore that he didn't want to do "IT" anymore or he had changed his mind or something of that sort, and Dumbledore told him that he had promised and he would do it and that was that. Basically anyways (definitely not verbatim).
Anyway, I am interested to hear how this fits into your theory. As I have said before, I LOVE to debate so please don't take my last sentence as sarcasm! I am wide open to anyone's interpretation of HP.
[/b]
|
okay...not really thought about that...
....here we go.....the IT you qoute could be snape working as the double agent....HA!....only joking
Quote:
Quote: |
...the person who removed Dd's body was hagrid. Say he was in on the plan and had instructions to switch the bodies for a fake one... [/b]
| Good, except that Hagrid couldn't keep a secret to save his life.
He could not have put on such a performance as he did
at the funeral if he knew that Dumbledore was alive.
I believe that Dumbledore or Snape placed an illusion on Hagrid.
[/b]
|
good point psyduck, and after reading you in depth explaination of what happened atop the astronemy tower i must concur and profess to agreeing with u