Both theories are good. Except...
Quote:
|
This did make me think about another possible side to this plot. It could be revealed that Dumbledore orchestrated his own death for the greater good. This is something that Harry needed to experience and understand because I think that Harry will be faced with this same choice in the end. Ever the teacher, Dumbledore killed 2 birds with one stone. Protected Malfoy and showed Harry what sacrifice is. [/b]
|
I've said somewhere before that Dumbledore is not crazy enough to kill himself and,
more importantly, that I don't want to believe that JKR would glorify suicide in a children's book.
Quote:
|
...the person who removed Dd's body was hagrid. Say he was in on the plan and had instructions to switch the bodies for a fake one... [/b]
|
Good, except that Hagrid couldn't keep a secret to save his life.
He could not have put on such a performance as he did
at the funeral if he knew that Dumbledore was alive.
I believe that Dumbledore or Snape placed an illusion on Hagrid.