Quote:
Okay feel free to post your theory on how Dumbledore is alive... or... dead.
My theory: (though it may seem impossible) Dumbledore was using polyjuice potion.
The incident where he argued with snape could have been Dumbledore in the guise of snape telling Dumbledore(snape) he no longer wanted to use the potion because it would be dangerous to snape. But Snape being loyal continues to use it. So in the end Snape was the one who really died. but i dont know if the potion works after someone stops living. I think Croutches mom may have still been in disguise when she died but maybe not the Dementors are blind after all arent they? Well i believe in the polyjuice potion for now. 
[/b]
|
I don't think this works because of the things Snape says at the end of HBP when Harry finally catches up with him.
You know, about how he was the HBP, and how he made up those spells, etc. . .I think that was really Snape.