the trelawney character wasn't great.she was too normal in the movie.the book trelawney is a melodramatic and over the top.Lupin was okay, but he is described as being young faced but tired looking and with a decent quantity of hair.I didn't like what they did to his face though.i'm not sure if they thouhgt they were being clever but all those supposed scratches from the transformations just really spoiled it.they gave the idea that they don't want to follow the movie and will do anyhting to prove it.