08-10-2005, 09:20 PM
|
| First Year | | Join Date: Jul 2005 Zodiac Sign:
Leo
Posts: 62
| |
Quote: Originally posted by awigo50@Aug 9 2005, 07:17 PM
You're not JK? Really? Like, not even in disquise, posing as just another fan! *Sighs, disappointedly* Oh well...
Very Funny!
Voldermort shows some caution. He doesn't meander about Diagon alley buying quills, does he? I think he knows that he can be overpowered and killed. As he has "never sought a duel with dumbledore" & considering his failed duel in the ministry, I would say that dumbledore was a enemy that dumbledore expected to be a worthy advisary.
I don't think its caution.* I think Voldemorts not meandering about Diagon Alley or the likes is because he thinks he's too good for such trivial things.* I mean if he thinks he's "all that" as the kids say, wouldn't he have servants to do his bidding?* I picture him sitting on some thrown (not a real thrown mind you,* some dark thing in a dark place) demanding this and that.* Until fight time.* But as you stated, his failed duel at the ministry,* neither he nor Dumbledore tried to kill the other did they?* This is a question, I can't remember the spells that flew back and forth.* I remember Voldemort trying to kill Harry and Dumbledore defending Harry with spells.* But, I may be wrong in that.* Anyway, my point lies in what I remember so feel free to correct me if I'm wrong.* Now, to my point, Voldemort didn't seem too worried about Dumbledore killing him at the Ministry.* He hung around to try to kill Harry even in Dumbledore's presence. If Voldemort killed Harry in front of Dumbledore wouldn't that tick off Dumbledore just a little?* I think that Dumbledore would kill him for sure for that and I'm sure if Voldemort was scared of Dumbledore for that reason, Voldemort would have high-tailed it out of there the minute he knew Dumbledore was there? Why would he stay and try to kill Harry in front of the one wizard he feared most, knowing to do so would bring Dumbledore's wrath down on him for sure?
Because he does not fear Dumbledore killing him!!!* He fears him for some other reason.
Someone Harry trusts with his life would have to know. Because that's what he's entrusting to accept snape back. And where is this person, so far away from Harry, that they couldn't attend Dumbledore's funeral and tell him? It just doesn't add up. If harry was going to be told about such a plot, it would have been in six.
Dumbledore entrusted Harry's safety to the entire ORDER!!!!* I mean that's what the whole ORDER is about, defeating Voldemort, and Harry is the only one who can do that!* The ORDER did not need to be told what to do if Dumbledore died!* They already knew what to do.* Protect Harry until the time comes for him to do HIS job!* No questions asked!* To the ORDER,* it doesn't matter if the killing was a plan or not.* They're mission remains the same with or without Dumbledore.* Only they're safer not knowing anything about a plan (if there was one).*
I really don't think Harry will ever forgive Snape for killing Dumbledore even if he knew it was an agreement.* I also think it won't matter because Snape will die for the cause in the end, he has to redeem himself doesn't he?
Unraveling and explaining the whole snape theory is going to take a chapter or two... And JK is already looking at a packed full book, considering Harry needs to kill half a dozen Horcruxs and Voldermort, stay at the dursleys, flirt with ginny, & attend Bill & fleur's wedding... And seven has to be shorter than OotP- "The benchmark" for how long a book can be according to JK, who still thinks it's too long, but can't find anything that could be cut.
One easy way to bring this conspiricy theory out would be Dumbledore's portrait in his office (McGonagall's office now).* I know, much too easy, but it could happen!* Dumbledore could have also left some memories in the pensieve or something.* Oh by the way, I liked your humor in that passage.
Then again, I wouldn't be sad or suprised if JK announced that the series was going to require a book 8...
I wish!*
What do you think Harry's odds are at finishing the series alive?*
[snapback]15044[/snapback] |  |