slytherin4me: yep I agree. James loved Lily and he got her and Lily loved James. The point is/ theory that, we're talking about (that is really, really, popular on EVERy chat site) is that Lupin loved Lily. This 'theory' started 'cause Jo said that something happened/ the director INADVERTENTLY put two things into the MOVIE of PoA that wasn't in the books, that INADVERTANTLY gave away stuff that would happen/ be uncovered, in the later books. (see postings/discussions in 'character analysis' for an abridged version of these theories).

I know that one of the theories (mentioned aove) was that Hermione beomes a werewolf but I've never heard the thought that 'Lily was a werewolf' before. You might be on to something original there @m@nd@!!!!