Slopeydope; "Sarcasm"!!!??? I don't even know how to spell it let a lone do it!! No sarcasm intended towards you in anyway, honest!! I love your feed back on this stuff it makes the waiting (I'm now living in JULY!!! (I'm a southern hemisphereer) YAY ! 15 days to go 'til HBP!!) so much more enjoyable.

I totally agree. It's a HUGE leap to go from 'Lily and Lupin in love' to 'Lupin is a spy'.
You will notice that now, as in my first post, I thought that the idea that Lupin was a Deatheater was pushin' it. I still reckon that he MIGHT have been so jealous of James that he became a Deatheater. I prefer the idea that he has slipped info (prob. via Petigrew) to Voldy. I am not necessarily saying that Lupin is a Deatheater- though, if you insist, I will - but I think he was/is more a spy, someone who gave info. to Voldemort. (That was confused sorry. I'm v. tired. Hope you follow it)

'Jo keeps her characters in 'character''????....ummm??? No. How about: Quirelle, Sirius Black, Mrs Figg, Bagman, Crouch Snr and 'Mad-eye Moody' even Petunia, just to name the most obvious. ie, I don't think Jo wants us to take people on face value at all! What's so different about Lupin??? It's not like he's a Weasley and we know all about him. There are things in his past that are dark. They might even include ummm.... ohhh! I dunno.... rattin' out his best mate and the women he loved 'cause he was ripped apart with jealousy...????... Just a thought

I totally agree. 'The Cedric Claus': Where Jo says a "major character is going to die" and she makes it Cedric Diggory!!??? Prob. be the same with HBP and all the theories within.

On Jo's official site, she says that though she won't say who the "missing Deatheater is, many fan sites have guessed right"......????? Isn't this even MORE frustrating??!

I still need to know (for this theory to really work in my mind) if it says in OotP, that LUPIN - as well as Dumb and Snape - was good at occulency. I know it's there somewhere!!! ?????????????